Three very totally different outcomes present there’s no assure
Though we’ve had a few of the finest financial savings charges in years, Premium Bonds stay widespread. Though there’s no assure in what you possibly can win, folks hope they could get fortunate and web large prizes – particularly if they’ve quite a lot of money invested.
To get an concept of how that pans out, I requested three folks with the utmost £50,000 saved what they gained in a 12 months. Although your individual scenario will differ, it’s a good way to know what your likelihood is.
Some articles on the weblog comprise affiliate hyperlinks, which offer a small fee to assist fund the weblog. Nevertheless, they gained’t have an effect on the value you pay or the weblog’s independence. Learn extra right here.
What are Premium Bonds?
Not like a financial savings account the place you get a assured return in your deposits – often called an rate of interest – Premium Bonds as an alternative have a Prize Charge.
This appears to be like like an rate of interest, but it surely really represents how a lot of the overall invested is given out in prizes. These prizes vary from £25 to £1 million. Right here’s extra on how they work.
What would you hope to win in a 12 months?
Within the final 12 months, the prize price has really modified 3 times, beginning at 3.75%, and going as much as 4.65%, earlier than dropping to 4.4% for the latest attracts.
- June and July draw 2023 – 3.75% prize price
- August draw 2023 – 4% prize price
- September 2023 to February 2024 attracts – 4.65% prize price
- March to Might 2024 – 4.4% prize price
When you add that each one collectively it provides a median prize price of 4.38%. That signifies that somebody with the complete £50,000 will hope to get a return of £2,190 in a 12 months.
It’s value noting although that the probability of getting near this price reduces you probably have much less cash held in PBs as you’ll successfully have fewer entries in to every draw, and subsequently fewer probabilities of successful.
Nonetheless, the prize price is a helpful shorthand for these with common luck. However would you have got common luck?
How a lot did £50k win over a 12 months?
Just a few years in the past, when financial savings charges have been notably poor, I had £10,000 in Premium Bonds for a full 12 months. And my expertise in that point was fairly good. I really beat the then price of 1%.
However since rates of interest elsewhere have improved I’ve solely had cash in PBs (as I wish to name them) on and off – successfully these months when the prize price was first rate, however transferring the money when it was overwhelmed.
Then final 12 months, I wrote about some mates who had saved the complete £50,000 money in Premium Bonds for six months – with stunning outcomes.
Now a full 12 months have handed, I requested them to share their additional wins – together with the outcomes from a 3rd pal – to see how issues panned out.
We’ll name them saver one, saver two and saver three! Listed here are all their prizes, month by month.
| Saver 1 | Saver 2 | Saver 3 | |
| June 2023 | £75.00 | £200.00 | £150.00 |
| July 2023 | £100.00 | £50.00 | £700.00 |
| August 2023 | £50.00 | £100.00 | £50.00 |
| September 2023 | £50.00 | £400.00 | £125.00 |
| October 2023 | £0.00 | £175.00 | £100.00 |
| November 2023 | £325.00 | £250.00 | £200.00 |
| December 2023 | £175.00 | £350.00 | £0.00 |
| January 2024 | £225.00 | £125.00 | £375.00 |
| February 2024 | £50.00 | £25.00 | £50.00 |
| March 2024 | £125.00 | £1,000.00 | £175.00 |
| April 2024 | £50.00 | £0.00 | £125.00 |
| Might 2024 | £200.00 | £275.00 | £175.00 |
| — | — | — | |
| Whole prizes | £1,425.00 | £2,950.00 | £2,225.00 |
| — | — | — | |
| Efficient win price | 2.85% | 5.90% | 4.45% |
You’ll be able to see simply how random it’s. All three had one month with no wins, however the quantity gained throughout the win differs massively.
Saver one fared worst, getting approach under the prize price with a poor 2.85% return, whereas saver two knocked it out of the park with an enormous 5.9% return. In the meantime the third saver wasn’t too far above the common price itself.
Why are the outcomes so totally different?
Neglect the rumours how newer bonds usually tend to win, that older bonds are typically excluded, that bonds which have already gained gained’t win once more and even that individuals exterior of London are at an obstacle.
These are all myths. Each single bond, new and outdated, throughout the UK, has the very same likelihood of successful one of many prizes. The one factor within the favour of those savours is which have extra entries due to having extra bonds.
However in the end is is simply right down to luck. Saver two was only a lot luckier than saver one, whereas saver three was just a bit luckier than common.
It’s an ideal instance of when somebody wins greater than anticipated, somebody misses out. At it’s most excessive in PBs, that’s proven when somebody wins actually large and lots of, many individuals win nothing in any respect.
And right here’s the loopy bit about our three savers. The overall mixed prize quantity was £6,600, with a median prize price of 4.4%. That’s solely rather less than the 12-month common prize price. Whereas the common for savers one and two was bang on 4.38%. It’s an ideal fluke to occur on such a small pattern, but it surely demonstrates all of it averages out!
Premium Bonds vs financial savings on £50k
So, we’ve established you possibly can do effectively or you possibly can do badly with Premium Bonds in comparison with the prize price. However what about for those who’d as an alternative put the cash in an easy accessibility financial savings account?
If our savers as an alternative had moved their cash from finest purchase to finest purchase in that interval (a complete of 5 transfers), they’d have gotten between 3.71% and 5.2%. In all however the first month, the highest rate of interest was increased than the prize price.
The typical rate of interest works out (roughly) as 4.87%, and with £50,000 saved you’d earn a median of £2,435 in assured curiosity. That’s in comparison with the common prize price of 4.38% and winnings of £2,190.
In our examples, solely saver two (a return of 5.9%) was really higher off with Premium Bonds, and each savers one (2.85%) and three (4.45%) ended up with much less. Nevertheless it’s not really that easy.
Tax on curiosity
First, it’s essential account for tax. Premium Bond prizes are tax-free, so there’s no curiosity on the return. Outdoors of PBs or ISAs, you might be taxed, however you may’t simply deduct the tax price from the rate of interest to get a correct comparability.
You additionally have to issue within the private financial savings allowance. Right here’s what placing the complete £50,000 in to financial savings on the common price would actually return (bear in mind the Premium Bond whole is common luck).
| Quantity | Charge | Tax-free | Whole curiosity after tax | Equal price after PSA & tax |
| Premium Bonds | 4.38% | All | £2,190.00 | 4.38% |
| Non taxpayer | 4.87% | All | £2,435.00 | 4.87% |
| Fundamental price taxpayer (20%) | 4.87% | £1,000 | £2,148.00 | 4.3% |
| Larger price taxpayer (40%) | 4.87% | £500 | £1,661.00 | 3.32% |
| Further price taxpayer (45%) | 4.87% | £0 | £1,339.25 | 2.68% |
So on this occasion, it nonetheless seems that Premium Bonds would have given one of the best return over this era. However as we all know not everybody will get the prize price, in order that solely applies to these with common luck.
Higher although could be as an alternative to combine financial savings and Premium Bonds, and benefit from the ISA allowances on high. So a fundamental price payer may put the primary £20,000ish into the highest paying non-ISA and the identical into ISAs (assuming for simplicity the identical common return), leaving £10,000 for PBs. Whereas a better price taxpayer would have £10,000 in a non-ISA and £20,000 in every of the ISAs and PBs.
Sadly we are able to’t ever calculate the true returns right here because it’s probably that somebody with £30,000 or £40,000 in PBs will win lower than somebody with £50,000 there. Nevertheless, if we maintain the common prize price at 4.38%, and mix it with the opposite tax-free returns, it may seem like this.
| Financial savings in PBs after PSA and PBs | Charge | Prizes | Curiosity elsewhere | Whole curiosity | Equal price |
| £10,000.00 (fundamental price taxpayer) | 4.38% | £438.00 | £2,000.00 | £2,438.00 | 4.88% |
| £20,000.00 (increased price taxpayer) | 4.38% | £876.00 | £1,500.00 | £2,376.00 | 4.75% |
No doubt, the mix is giving one of the best total returns on cash – for somebody with common luck.
And if we put in a nasty (although not worst case) state of affairs the place the prize returns have been simply 1% on the extra money, you’d nonetheless match returns after tax for a fundamental price taxpayer who put every part in easy-access financial savings and beat it as a better price taxpayer.
| Financial savings in PBs after PSA and PBs | Charge | Prizes | Curiosity elsewhere | Whole curiosity | Equal price |
| £10,000.00 (fundamental price taxpayer) | 1.5% | £150 | £2,000.00 | £2,150 | 4.3% |
| £20,000.00 (increased price taxpayer) | 1.5% | £300 | £1,500.00 | £1,800 | 3.6% |
So, for those who’re after a assured return relatively than depend on luck, you’re nonetheless higher off utilizing your PSA and ISAs allowances first.
In fact, extra price taxpayers solely get the ISA tax-free returns, in order that they’d be higher off with PBs over different financial savings with financial savings of this measurement.
Incomes curiosity on the prizes
One other issue to contemplate is you may’t reinvest prizes into PBs if you have already got the complete £50k saved. Which suggests our three savers all (hopefully) moved their winnings right into a excessive paying account to maintain incomes, maybe as a lot as 7% through common saver, then they’d earn extra on high – even when tax was doubtlessly due on that.
Smaller balances
And naturally, our savers all had the entire £50,000 to avoid wasting. Most individuals gained’t have wherever close to that. So how a lot would beat the 4.38% common Premium Bond prize with the assured returns from the common financial savings price of 4.87% on this interval?
A fundamental price tax payer would wish £30,000 or much less in different accounts to beat PBs, and a better price taxpayer would wish £12,000 or much less. And naturally, there are are ISAs too.
Additionally, regardless that extra price taxpayers would pay tax on all earnings exterior of an ISA, they’d nonetheless have to win sufficient every year to match the two.68% after tax price elsewhere.
Get one of the best of our cash saving content material each Thursday, straight to your inbox
+ Get a £20 Quidco bonus (new members solely). Extra particulars
Are Premium Bonds value it?
Andy’s evaluation
As demonstrated, there’s no assure you’ll do effectively with Premium Bonds. I feel getting a assured financial savings price that beats the prize price is best than the slim probability of successful large.
However, there are occasions after they’re value a shot. As I skilled earlier than the bottom price hikes boosted financial savings charges, there will be events the place Premium Bonds web you more money. That was particularly the case when financial savings charges have been under 1%. Nevertheless, it’s unlikely we’ll return to these ranges any time quickly, if in any respect.
Extra related to now’s for these with massive sums saved up. When you’re already filling your private financial savings allowance (or for those who don’t get one) and have maxed out the annual ISA allowance (maybe in shares and shares relatively than money), Premium Bonds could be a good choice.
However, you do need to ask whether or not you want such important sums in money – typically you solely really want to cowl large forthcoming spending and 6 to 12 months of important bills.
